There is a lot of argument of who this century belongs to?
India or China. I have found an alternative view in this, which I feel would
provide you with a new perspective. I have found a strange similarity between
today’s India & China with that of 19th century Germany &
France.
From the time of the collapse of Charlemagne’s empire, France had been
the dominant power on continental Europe. It’s biggest advantage was
demography. According to estimates till the beginning of 19th
century, France was the 3rd most populous nation on Earth after
China & India. However, after the French revolutionary wars & the
Napoleonic wars in the period 1789 to 1815, France lost a lot of young men in
war. In terms of proportion of population it lost more than Germany in world
war one. It was a loss that France failed to recover from. On the contrary
Germany rapidly industrialised in the 19th century since the
formation of Zollverin & especially after reunification in 1871. It’s
population also grew rapidly with that till by the end of the 19th
century it had overtaken France & Britain in population size. It became the
dominant power in Europe not just through industrialization, but also by
winning the demographic war. What has all this got to do with 21st
century India & China. Well, on one hand India’s population is growing
rapidly with no politician or political party with the guts to control it( As
they fear that they would loose popularity & hence the elections), on the
other hand, China keeps a tight lease on its population with its one child
policy being a dictatorial state. Some predictions even show that India would
overtake China in population by 2022. While this is concerning initially- that
bigger & younger population mean more unemployment & more people to
feed, cloth & house, there is also a brighter side to this. After all,
India too is rapidly industrializing & bigger population means bigger
market & economy. India may just actually make this century hers by winning
the demographic war against China, just like Germany did with France in the 19th
century.
But there is also another similarity that we can compare
today’s China-India situation. In the 19th century, Germany grew
partly due to the discipline that it was provided with by the dictatorial
states that existed in Germany at that time- biggest example is that of
Prussia. On the other hand there was another nation that took a great part in
this second industrial revolution that was taking place in the 19th
century. This nation was United States of America- a chaotic democracy with
lots of corruption & indiscipline. But by the end of the 19th
century, it was not this disciplined, militarised dictatorial Germany that won
the race. It was the USA that emerged as the largest economy on the planet
thereby paving the way of the 20th century to be the American
century. What could possibly be a more closer example of dictatorial,
disciplined China & chaotic, free India?
These examples show us that what
matters is who is going to win in the long term. India may not overtake China
in 5-10 or even 20 years, but in the long run it will be the winner.
No comments:
Post a Comment